Every headline-worthy insurance claim starts the same way: with someone thinking, “That won’t happen to me.” But major verdicts, settlements, and lawsuits happen every day, often to businesses and individuals who never saw it coming. The situations below aren’t theoretical, they actually occurred, and the financial consequences were substantial. These cases show how quickly things can escalate and why having the right insurance coverage is essential.
Delivery Driver Receives $50 Million Verdict Due to Being Burned by Scalding Tea — Liability
A California jury awarded a delivery driver $50 million after he was seriously burned when hot tea spilled on his lap at a drive-through. The negligence lawsuit alleged that the coffee shop employee did not properly wedge the tea firmly enough into the takeout tray. The resulting injuries required skin grafts and other medical procedures, and according to the plaintiff’s attorneys, the man suffered permanent and life-changing disfigurement. The defendant, a coffeehouse, has stayed they plan to appeal the verdict.
Texas County Jury Awards Over $20 Million to Women After Apartment Complex Fall — Liability
A Texas women received a $20.15 million verdict after sustaining injuries in a fall at an apartment complex. According to the lawsuit, the woman was walking down stairs to the apartment complex parking lot when the stairs began to bounce and move. This movement led her to fall and subsequent injuries. The lawsuit alleged the apartment complex managers failed to maintain and repair the steps, creating the conditions that caused the fall. The verdict listed that the judgement covers physical and mental pain, disfigurement, impairment and medical expenses.
National Drugstore Chain Agrees to $6.8 Million Settlement After Data Breach — Cyber
A national drugstore chain agreed to settle a class-action lawsuit that arose following a 2024 data breach, and the $6.8 million settlement received preliminary approval from a Pennsylvania district court judge. According to the lawsuit, hackers accessed the personal data of approximately 2.2 million customers and the company failed to notify the affected individuals for over a month. The suit alleged that information, including names, addresses, birth dates and purchase data, had been compromised. The breach occurred when a cybercriminal impersonated an employee to gain access to the system in 2024 and exposed the information of customers who made purchases through the company between June 2017 and July 2018. The lawsuit further alleged that this breach could have been prevented since another breach impacted the chain in 2023. As part of the settlement, the company agreed to implement enhanced data security measures. Members of the class-action suit are eligible for claims up to $10,000.
Security Firm Agrees to Pay $1.6 Million to Settle Sex Discrimination Lawsuit — Employment Practices Liability
A security solutions firm headquartered in Alabama has agreed to settle allegations of discriminatory hiring practices levied by the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) for $1.6 million. The EEOC claimed that the firm had denied women security officer jobs and assignments in 2017. The regulators stated the firm’s HR database instructed staff to exclude women from being scheduled for certain roles and labeled specific positions as men-only. This occurred despite women having relevant backgrounds. The EEOC also explained that the firm’s staff admitted to women applicants that they could not be selected for security roles because of their sex. Per the three-year decree that resolves the lawsuit, the payment must be provided to the women applicants who were denied opportunities for the jobs. The firm must also remove instructions that barred women from being hired, assigned or selected based on their sex.
No matter your size or industry, it’s essential to understand where you’re exposed and whether your current coverage is enough. If this raised questions about your business coverage or risk exposure, let’s talk.
About The Plexus Groupe
The Plexus Groupe is a Top 100 independent insurance advisory firm, backed by our knowledgeable team, cutting-edge resources, and a global network of partnerships. We specialize in comprehensive services across Business Insurance, Employee Benefits, Private Client solutions, Retirement Services, and Mergers & Acquisitions.
As a proud partner of Assurex Global – the world’s largest association of privately held insurance brokers – our risk management professionals provide tailored solutions to meet the diverse needs of our clients worldwide.
Headquartered in Deer Park, III., with additional offices across the U.S., The Plexus Groupe is committed to delivering personalized service, innovative solutions, and strategic insights that empower clients to thrive in today’s complex environment. Visit www.plexusgroupe.com to learn more.
This publication is intended for informational purposes only and is not intended to be exhaustive, nor should any discussion or opinions be construed as professional advice. Readers should contact a licensed insurance professional or attorney for appropriate advice. ©2025 Zywave, Inc. All rights reserved.
